‘A fat man eating quails while children are begging for bread is a disgusting sight, but you are less likely to see it when you are within sound of the guns.’ George Orwell, Homage to Catalonia.
For the last four days I have been sick with diarrhea and general queasiness. It came on while we were in Bluebay Resort in Zanzibar. I really wish it had come on a day later, so I could blame an outbreak of malaria on Precision Airways’ leaving my doxyclycline, but, since my condition predates the airline’s misconduct, I’ll have to savor my grudge without malaria. I’ll settle. Perhaps I’ll lose some of the weight that surrounds my queasy stomach.
This trip to Tanzania is a bitch.
From June 23 to June 29 we did an epic drive across Tanzania from Dar es Salaam to Makete and back, close to forty hours of driving.
Dar to Njombe is on the A-6 national road, a two lane tarmac that is one of the best roads in the country, and indeed, where it is unpotholed and away from the villages, a pretty decent road, but there are frequent patches where the surface is pocked by unmarked 15 cm deep holes, and there are speed bumps, as well, the Tanzanian road crews apparently not understanding the Major’s explanation that Romania—in an unaccustomed economy of effort—didn’t need both potholes and speed bumps. After road hazards in the form of other traffic have been added, the ride amounts to lots of rapid acceleration and urgent braking.
Near the villages, pedestrians and bicycles fill the road’s edges. Bicycles carry 2 or 3 2m by 1m bundles of charcoal, bundles of 4m planks, canisters of water and bundles of thatch. Mr. Kapezi, our driver, is no bicycler. He forces our Landcruiser around lorries and dalidalis (15 passenger vans, usually carrying 30 or more passengers) in the face of oncoming bicycle traffic, sending them and their loads into the ditch.
On the road from Iringa to Njombe, as we followed the Baobab valley, approaching the escarpment of the Somthi Ngorotha Mountains at a speed of 120 kph (84 mph), we rounded a curve as a boy, size 8 or 9, but 10 or 12 in Tanzanian years, I suppose, with a 20-25 kilo bag of maize on his head, stepped into our path. He stood there dumbstruck as our Toyota skewed through a 90 degree skid. We heard no telltale thump, and our attention turned to the approaching rock wall, with which we became suddenly well acquainted, but somehow missed. On the realization that we had neither flipped nor crashed, I looked back to see the boy bounding into the brush on one side of the road as his brother, I suppose, dropped his bag and ran the other way. Mr. Kapezi and I unbuckled and got out. The boy’s bursted bag and shoe lay in the middle of the road. Mr. Kapezi picked them up and carried them to the side of the road, calling to the boy that it was alright and that he could come back. He didn’t show and neither did his brother.
We examined the car. We thought for a moment that the tread had separated from the left rear tire, but it turned out the loose tread we saw was debris from an earlier accident. We drove on, leaving only our dramatic four-stroke curving skid marks and a blotch of corn meal in the road. I wondered if the boy would be punished for wasting food.
****
June 26. After a night in Njombe and three hours of rutted mountain road, we arrive in Makete. Makete is a poor region in a poor country. Men from Makete seek work elsewhere as miners, plantation workers, drivers and soldiers. On infrequent trips home they bring HIV, and Makete is widely described as the ‘epicenter’ of AIDS in Tanzania.
The purpose of our trip is to examine the functioning of the ‘Most Vulnerable Children’s Committees’ structure in Makete as part of our larger examination of the child welfare capacity of Tanzania. We’ve talked about the MVCCs before, and will again, so I’ll only summarize. The MVCCs are a lovely, delicate attempt to formalize the traditional village system to care for orphans and vulnerable children. The Tanzanian government, lacking resources to create a paid and sustainable system of child welfare, has initiated MVCC committees in the villages. These are volunteers, unpaid and largely unskilled members of the community, who identify the most vulnerable children (MVC) in the community and report their numbers and needs to the district government. The MVCCs are supposed to mobilize and coordinate resources and support. In theory the district government directs resources to the village MVCCs to address the children’s needs. In theory, the village reports are incorporated into a district plan. In theory, the district plan is shared with the donor-funded NGOs, who, in theory, use the plan to allocate their resources and to deliver essential aid to the MVC in the villages.
We were to meet the District Executive Director, but he was on ‘safari’ (it just means a 'trip'), as was the Deputy. We made do with the Human Resource Officer, the Social Welfare Officer and a number of district level departmental officers. Essentially, the government departmental officers described a system that is working more or less as it was described in the written plan, so I’ll skip ahead for now.
****
On June 27 we went to two villages, Ndulamo and Ivalolila. In each village we met with the MVCC members. These meetings were simultaneously heart-rending and heart-warming. In each village, committee members met us in mud-walled school rooms to describe their activities. In communities of ~700 and ~500 children, the committees have identified 253 and 260 MVC respectively. These are the ones who are lacking food, shelter, school uniforms or exercise books, or bedding. The MVCC members told us that they know of only one or two NGOs who are providing assistance. One NGO delivered 20 ‘iron sheets’, that is corrugated iron, to mend roofs for five children. Another delivered 20 school uniforms and food for 20 children and 60 exercise books. And that’s pretty much it for outside assistance. As for the rest, the community taxes themselves, 100 Tanzanian shillings—that’s 9 cents—a month per household, but not all households can pay it, and the government, mostly the Ministry of Education puts in a little money, and when we do the math it turns out that there is about $2 a year of support per most vulnerable child, and then there is the community plot. The villages have set aside one or two hectares (e.g., 2.5 to 5.0 acres) to grow food for the most vulnerable children. They grow Irish potatoes. According to calculations we have made elsewhere, it takes about a dollar a day per child to provide food, clothing, shelter and education.
We met with a bunch of caregivers, seventeen little old grannies, probably younger than Lucia and I, but looking like the dawn of time. They are toothless and bent and they walk with sticks. They throw their sticks under a bench outside the school house and help each other struggle over the threshold. In traditional kangas they seat themselves on the benches like flowers. We briefly introduce ourselves, and the translator translates, they clap for every sentence. Some ululate. Merick, our translator, a young lawyer, counselor to the District Executive Director, tells us this is traditional and simply means that they are happy to see us, yet we have a hollow chilly fear that the enthusiasm is because they think we bring money.
One of our colleagues asks a question, ‘What do you do when you don’t have enough food for the children?’ and I hate this question, no doubt because I fear the answer, but the answer comes back: ‘We send the children into the forest to cut wood to take to the market to sell. Then we buy food.’
Once upon a time there was a boy named Jack who lived with an old woman in a very poor house at the edge of the forest and one day his grandmother said to him, ‘My boy, you must go into the forest to cut some wood… .’ And there you have it, the classic tale, but without the magic beans. So far, they do not live happily ever after. We heard the same or similar stories in three other villages in two other districts.
****
7/8/2006
So today we are in Ngorongoro Crater. The previous three days we were in the Serengeti. I am standing in the back of a Toyota Landcruiser under the canopy of the lifted roof. The wind is in my hair. Binoculars at the ready, I am Rommel, scanning the horizon for enemy rhinoceros and light armored cape buffalo. We scour the trees for sniper leopards. We are consumed by guilt, but last night we enjoyed the obscenity of a mixed grill and tonight I’m asking the chef to fix me some quails.